On U List of Movie Reviews

(For optimum viewing, adjust the zoom level of your browser to 125%.)


Umberto D. (1952)

Rate: 5
Viewed: 8/06

UmbD
8/06: Although Umberto D. is considered as a classic of world cinema, I beg to differ.

While the movie is emotionally moving at times, it's never fulfilling because of the lack of depth within the protagonist. Worse, he doesn't seem to be in any state of despair. The explanations aren't clear, either. So, the dog takes over in an attempt to manipulate my feelings, so I can say, "Oh, how cute!"

By eliminating the animal from the equation, I doubt Umberto D. would be the film as it is. Hence, Ladri di biciclette is more honest about a working class male who's desperate to do anything given the deplorable circumstances. Vittorio De Sica tried to do the same with the old man and his dog, but it's rather tacky.

All in all, to like Umberto D. is to fall for the trap that's laid by the dog.